أفضل طريقة لنقض تقرير الخبير |

Peace, mercy, and blessings of God be upon you. We were in a session when the shocking expert report arrived, contradicting reality and containing many fallacies and errors that warrant its annulment. Is it possible to amend the expert report, overturn it, or replace the expert? Or is it simply that the court will rule 100% based on the expert's report, without any effort or the need for a

detailed response and the necessary critique? This is a misconception. You imagine that the court will rule based on the expert's report without review, discussion, modification, or amendment, and that the expert's decision is unchangeable. Many cases have come before me, you, and many lawyers and litigants where the court discussed the expert's opinion and disregarded it. In

some cases, the court asked the expert to revise the report and pay attention to certain points. In others, the court completely disregarded the expert's opinion and appointed another expert to examine the point of contention. In some cases, and in many others, the court ruled based on the expert's opinion. So, the court can rule based on the expert's opinion, and this

expert is appointed by the court. The judicial body selected the expert, assigning her a specific task. But does this delegation and appointment by the judicial body mean the matter is closed? No. Why do I say such a thing? Some people neglect to provide a detailed and thorough response. Some imagine it's pointless, thus missing a

significant opportunity. Consequently, the court might adopt the expert's report because you didn't give a productive and appropriate response to the expert's decision. God willing, in another episode, I will discuss in detail, according to the rules of evidence, how to discuss the expert's opinion, respond to the expert, and whether or not the expert can be changed. May God grant us all success.